Pie Tarts: What to Do With Extra Crust

I made these tarts about a week ago and haven’t had the time to put up the post until now.  I don’t actually know what to classify them as, because they technically are not tarts.  Buuuuut, since that’s what my mom always called them, that’s what they are.  So, there.

I hate wasting pie scraps… even when cookie recipes call for not rolling out the dough twice, I do not listen.  So, make these after your next pie!  OR, you can be as irrational as I and just cut the pie dough recipe you use regularly in half and make a whole big batch! They really are just that good.


Buttermilk Pie Dough (already cut in half)

1 1/4 cup flour
1/2 cup shortening/butter
1 1/2 tsp sugar
1/2 tsp salt
1/4 cup buttermilk (cold cold cold cold)

Follow the directions for mixing the pie dough from this post.

Tart Filling

maybe 1/2 cup butter
1/4 cup brown sugar
3 tsp cinnamon
(that’s it! SOOOO EASY!)
Note: this recipe is not exact.  It’s more like… “Well, that looks like enough sugar” or “Gee, I think I’ll have to give this to the dog.”  Especially if you are using your scraps, then you won’t have to use as much for the filling.


Preheat your oven to 350F.  Divide your pie dough into three parts.  Roll out your pie dough.  It’s probably not as necessary to let your pie dough chill as long as the recipe says for this little project if you’re only making the tarts minus the pie.  Do your best to roll the dough out into a long rectangle.  You want to roll everything up when you’re done length-wise, so keep that in mind.

Once your dough is rolled out nice and thin then, spread on enough butter.  Enough to make you think future heart problems but NOT instant heart attack.  Okay?  Then sprinkle brown sugar over top, enough to hide all that frightening butter.  THEN, shake on some cinnamon, enough to almost cover all the sugar.  Cinnamon is dangerous.  You can go overboard.

Then, carefully, pull up one side of the pie dough with your fingers and start to roll everything up into a long tube.  Remember, to do this length-wise, so you don’t have super fat tarts, but rather a long roll.  Then, cut up the roll into about one inch rolls.

Put foil over a cookie-sheet and then arrange the tarts on it.  Put in the oven for 25-30 minutes or until the dough feels firm to the touch OR until the sugar starts to turn a deeeeeep brown almost black.  I like to let my sugar and butter caramelize almost to the point of burning.  It makes for a AWESOME crunchy layer on the bottom!

DSC_0273 DSC_0274
DSC_0283 DSC_0030
Make some coffee, sit down with a book and eat eat eat eat eat!  You won’t be able to stop.

10 thoughts on “Pie Tarts: What to Do With Extra Crust

  1. heads up…your instructions say to put brown sugar on twice…and no cinnamon. you may want to revise! 😉
    sounds delicious! my roommate is the one who makes pies, so perhaps when she does again, i’ll have to steal her extra pie crust dough! 🙂

  2. Hey!!! That is your grandma’s recipe! Did you give her credit? This is the very first thing I can remember learning how to make as a young child. I wasn’t allowed to eat the raw dough though – back then flour was often mealy and you would get worms. At least that is what Mom always said. Yours looks really yummy, Trev! Gooey and chewy!

    • I absolutely love your comment! And these faux tarts look simply amazing. Is Trevor still writing? I love this site!

      Merry Christmas!

      • Hey Suzanne! I don’t write here anymore actually. 😦 I just so t have any extra time for it. It was a great season though being able to share about my little kitchen in Peru. I hope one day to be able to pick this back up again. Thanks for stopping by and enjoy everything that’s here!!! 🙂

      • How fabulous are you? Answering me so quickly! And at 1:36am ET! I am sad that you are no longer writing here, but I’m happy that you are busy enjoying your life! You are truly a breath of fresh air! May you and yours have a very, Merry Christmas, Trevor!

Well, what do you think? Leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s